Jump to content
NBC Sports Edge Forums


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Community Reputation

6 Neutral

About Topkat

  • Rank

Previous Fields

  • Add to Mailing List?
  1. I would do it, JRob has a pretty rough playoff schedule with Ravens and Bears. Edmonds may even take over the starting gig in a few weeks.
  2. I wouldn’t do Golladay for Chubb straight up. Even when Chubb returns, Hunt will still get his touches and remain a top 15 back. Even before injury, Chubb was not scoring much more than Hunt. I would stay out rather than sacrifice your WR depth. But if you’re intent on getting Chubb, then I would try get a mud-tier WR back.
  3. Of the 3 WRs, Keenan has the best playoffs schedule, so that would be my target. I also like Herbert better than Tannehill. So maybe something like: Boyd/Gibson/Tannehill for Keenan/Herbert/lesser RB
  4. The league has deep bench slots and nothing is of value there, so I picked up Herbert and originally tried to trade Herbert to the owner for one of those RBs, since he only has Newton. But he then countered with these 2 offers for my Wilson.
  5. Was offered: 1) Jacobs for my Wilson or 2) Hunt for my Wilson 10-team 0.5ppt ppr league Start 1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1TE, 1 RB/WR/TE Flex My lineup: QB: Wilson, Brady, Herbert RB: Kamara, Robinson, Gaskin, Chubb WR: Metcalf, AJBrown, Thielen, Godwin, Woods, Boyd, Antonio Brown TE: J Smith Should I accept either of these 2 trade offers to get extra depth at RB for downgrade in QB?
  6. I would definately take Lamar side! Question is whether the other side will accept that trade. Mostert has been out for much of the season, and when he comes back, no telling he may reinjure his ankle again and be out for season.
  7. I would start JRob based on higher floor and upside. Gibson hasn't had a 100-yd game all season, so not sure why he would break out. Plus he is now in 50/50 split with McKissic. Can you reply to mine:
  8. Receive: Davante Adams, Chris Carson, Gronk Give: Gurley, DJ Moore, Henry 10-team 1pt PPR league - start 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1TE, 1 Flex My lineup: QB: Wilson RB: Chubb, Jacobs, Gurley, Freeman, Fournette WR: McLaurin, Moore, Chark, Claypool, Lamb TE: Henry, Tonyan Should I accept this trade? Get upgrades at RB and WR, but downgrade at TE.
  9. It is close, but I would start Bridgewater over Burrow, just because CAR will likely have to chase points vs NO. Plus Burrow is allergic to TDs.
  10. Receive: Jacobs and Woods Give: Aaron Jones 10-team 1pt PPR league - Start 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 Flex My lineup: QB: Brady, Herbert RB: Jones, Connor, Robinson, McKinnon, Lindsay WR: Hill, Kupp, Higgins, Chark, Fulgham TE: Henry, Smith Should I accept this trade? Is it worth giving up the best player to get extra depth?
  11. I would take the Zeke side, so by all means can try to propose it.
  12. I would stay put. A lot has to go right trading 2 healthy players for 2 injured ones.
  13. Definitely take Thomas. You need studs for playoffs. One or two weeks out does not make Thomas equivalent to Lamb.
  14. If you don’t want to give up Hill or Evans, then you can try to package Chubb with Lamb or Brown for Jon Taylor or Gurley + one of their WRs.
  • Create New...