Jump to content
NBC Sports EDGE Forums

Make this deal?


Recommended Posts

Team in sig.

Picked 9th out of 12 in league draft. My plan of getting Megatron and then Fitz with the 2nd pick did not work out.

I'm a huge Larry fan-- so tell me if I am crazy.

I GIVE:

Megatron

Dallas Clark

I GET:

Fitzgerald

Jermichael Finley

Thoughts- I considered taking Larry in the 1st round over Megatron. Look what he did last year with no one at QB... Most sites have Clark ahead of Finley-- but Rotoworld doesn't. I believe he COULD be the "next Gates"... But Clark may be a safer pick--- I DO have Peyton Manning and would be losing "hook-up points".... Although the Colts have a full crop of healthy WRs this year, so less targets for Clark... does PPR for TE's make the deal bad for me?

Thanks!

WHIR

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'd do the deal.

It really comes down to personal preference though. Its pretty much a dead even trade.

I like Fitz over Megatron (mostly because I don't think Stafford will stay healthy)

Finley is a bigger injury risk than Clark but has way more upside.

I'd rather have Fitz and Finley (and actually do in a couple leagues)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pretty much even I say, as both WRs and TEs are pretty evenly ranked. If you prefer Fitz to Megatron, then do it.

Not sure a Stafford injury creates much impact as I don't recall Megatron losing much with Hill throwing the ball last year.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's dead-even as far as I'm concerned, so take the side that "floats your boat". Seriously, you're trading elite WR/TE for elite WR/TE. You are giving the WR with lightly more risk, but getting the TE with slightly more risk.

It's really a push.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Team in sig.

Picked 9th out of 12 in league draft. My plan of getting Megatron and then Fitz with the 2nd pick did not work out.

I'm a huge Larry fan-- so tell me if I am crazy.

I GIVE:

Megatron

Dallas Clark

I GET:

Fitzgerald

Jermichael Finley

Thoughts- I considered taking Larry in the 1st round over Megatron. Look what he did last year with no one at QB... Most sites have Clark ahead of Finley-- but Rotoworld doesn't. I believe he COULD be the "next Gates"... But Clark may be a safer pick--- I DO have Peyton Manning and would be losing "hook-up points".... Although the Colts have a full crop of healthy WRs this year, so less targets for Clark... does PPR for TE's make the deal bad for me?

Thanks!

WHIR

I'm not so sure I see a side that wins out in this trade. I think this dwindles down to which receiver/TE you like the best. For me, that'd be the side you'd give up.

help? http://forums.rotoworld.com/index.php?showtopic=241062

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...