Who wins this trade? WHIR

[6Kill]

Side A - Gets Story and Meadows

Side B - Gets Baez and JD Martinez

 

WHIR

[charger_ss24]

I like A personally. Fair enough enough trade for both parties.

[LJJr]

Prefer A but it's reasonably fair.

[Rush2112]

Whatever players you own keep those, counter and move some mt for the other duo. 

[ty5592]

Redraft B

Dynasty/keeper A

[Thenewwildone8]

8 hours ago, 6Kill said:

Side A - Gets Story and Meadows

Side B - Gets Baez and JD Martinez

 

WHIR

I think that Story is the best player in this deal and I like Meadows’s potential. JDM is good but he had back issues last year and will likely decline soon.

[thebestpr21]

B for me. Im not as high on Meadows as most. Really high injury risk IMO. JD and Baez are both top consistent hitters and fairly low risk health wise. I think the difference between meadows and either of them is very significant.

[Thenewwildone8]

14 minutes ago, thebestpr21 said:

B for me. Im not as high on Meadows as most. Really high injury risk IMO. JD and Baez are both top consistent hitters and fairly low risk health wise. I think the difference between meadows and either of them is very significant.

You don’t think Story is better than both though?

[TheTruth024]

About as fair that a trade can get.  Story > Baez, and JDM > Meadows.  If I had to pick, I guess I like the Story side a little more, due to the strikeouts and not so good OBP from Baez.  Plus side A is getting more SB's out of it, so side A slightly wins

Edited March 14, 2020 by TheTruth024

[thebestpr21]

11 hours ago, Thenewwildone8 said:

You don’t think Story is better than both though?

I do, but I think the gap between them and Meadows is a lot bigger than the gap between Story and them. 

[Backdoor Slider]

16 hours ago, Rush2112 said:

Whatever players you own keep those, counter and move some mt for the other duo. 

So I was truly never sure. Wondered if Rush was a special needs dude in his mom’s basement or the ultimate troll. This seals it. Troll level 100!

Oh, and side A slightly.

[Thenewwildone8]

3 hours ago, thebestpr21 said:

I do, but I think the gap between them and Meadows is a lot bigger than the gap between Story and them. 

Fair point, why do you think Meadows is a high injury risk? 

[thebestpr21]

4 hours ago, Thenewwildone8 said:

Fair point, why do you think Meadows is a high injury risk? 

I believe he had issues staying healthy as he was coming up as a MLB top prospect. Maybe Im confusing him with someone else? Even if I am, i still take B. 

[sjs1890]

I like side A the best.

Story is the best player in the deal and I like the more balanced stats you get with the sb's from side A.

 

 

[Gabelife]

I'd go with B because I like Baez.  Never liked Story that much.

 

[Call me Red]

Both sides are good tbh.  I guess it would come down to personal preference.  Help with mine?