Backdoor Slider 8,273 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 I’m staying away from the Ty Cobb/Hank Greenberg types. Think it’s more interesting to stick with guys we’ve seen play. I think the Tigers are relatively easy (and boring). Miguel Cabrera (one of great RHH of last 40 years) Justin Verlander Alan Trammell Lou Whitaker The 4th name is probably the only one up for debate, but over 70 career bWAR. Seriously underrated. Hard to pick Magglio or Scherzer types who didn’t play majority of career here. That said, really interested to see some others. Indians, Yankees, Jays are a few teams I know well, and would have difficulty cutting it to 4. Who you got? 3 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
tonycpsu 5,252 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 Mike Schmidt Steve Carlton Chase Utley Jimmy Rollins 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
6Kill 584 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 Derek Jeter Mariano Rivera Andy Pettitte This 4th spot has me torn up inside (really wanna go Don Mattingly) but I'm gonna give it to Bernie Williams. 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
mjb03003 1,974 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 Pedro Martinez David Ortiz Manny Ramirez Dustin Pedroia honorable mention: Mookie Betts 2 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
BackyardBaseball 265 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 Ken Griffey Jr Randy Johnson Alex Rodriguez Ichiro 2 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
LJJr 230 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 Atlanta is kinda a tough one... But I think I have to go: Chipper Maddux Glavine Smoltz Honorable Mention: Freeman, Murphy, Andruw Jones... Didn't get to see Aaron play or he'd be there for sure 3 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Members_Only_76 7,252 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 Robin Yount Paul Molitor Prince Fielder Christian Yelich 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Sidearmer 2,125 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 (edited) Jose Reyes David Wright Mike Piazza Jacob deGrom Caveat: If I was older I'd include Keith and Seaver or Reyes and Piazza. Edited March 25, 2020 by Sidearmer 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
tucker26 2,324 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 (Not a fan of Reds, just Votto...) 3 2 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
sngehl01 917 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 The in my lifetime part makes it way easier. Jeff Bagwell Craig Biggio Lance Berkman Roy Oswalt ... Billy Wagner was tough to snub. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Junkie Cosmonaut 702 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 Frank Thomas Harold Baines - Has no business being in the HOF, but he was the face of the White Sox for about 7-8 years in the 80s Paul Konerko Mark Buerhle Just missed: Fisk - Regardless of his time here, I always think Red Sox when I think Fisk Sale - Best White Sox pitcher I'll likely ever see, but can't stand him. F him, his scissors and his affection for Drake LaRoche's leadership. Ventura - Boring player, boring person. 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
jb_power 3,464 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 Roberto Clemente Barry Bonds Willie Stargell Dave Parker Tough choice on #4 between Parker and Andrew McCutcheon 2 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
BayofPuigs 107 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 Kershaw Piazza Kemp Bellinger Feel like I might be missing someone 2 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
tucker26 2,324 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 6 minutes ago, BayofPuigs said: Kershaw Piazza Kemp Bellinger Feel like I might be missing someone Manny, Hanley, Crawford and Puig? Quote Link to post Share on other sites
mjb03003 1,974 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 19 minutes ago, BayofPuigs said: Kershaw Piazza Kemp Bellinger Feel like I might be missing someone Shawn Green? Eric Gagne? 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Backdoor Slider 8,273 Posted March 25, 2020 Author Share Posted March 25, 2020 1 hour ago, 6Kill said: Derek Jeter Mariano Rivera Andy Pettitte This 4th spot has me torn up inside (really wanna go Don Mattingly) but I'm gonna give it to Bernie Williams. Was interested to dig deeper. Bernie edges him in fWAR, wRC+. Seems the right call by the closest of margins (then include championships). 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Heretic 114 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 Keith Wright Doc Piazza 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Cmilne23 10,544 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 Griffey Arod Randy Edgar Martinez just missed: Ichiro honorable mention: nobody else. They all sucked besides those 5. 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
jimmyjohns 48 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 Andre Dawson Ryne Sandberg Sammy Sosa ... Mark Grace, Rick Sutcliffe or Tony Rizzo. None of them hold a candle to the top 3. Quote Link to post Share on other sites
JE7HorseGod 2,640 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 The Machine The Wizard Jimmy Ballgame Big Mac Quote Link to post Share on other sites
6Kill 584 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 44 minutes ago, Cmilne23 said: Griffey Arod Randy Edgar Martinez just missed: Ichiro honorable mention: nobody else. They all sucked besides those 5. I’m no Mariners expert, but my buddy who’s a huge fan has Ichiro in over ARod and gives an honorable mention to King Felix Quote Link to post Share on other sites
2ndCitySox 4,462 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 White Sox: Big Hurt Buehrle Konerko Fisk Also, in front of the monument I'd put a bronze statue of Steve Lyons dropping his pants at first base. 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
2ndCitySox 4,462 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 54 minutes ago, JE7HorseGod said: The Machine The Wizard Jimmy Ballgame Big Mac Who is Jimmy Ballgame. Edmonds? Quote Link to post Share on other sites
JE7HorseGod 2,640 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 Just now, 2ndCitySox said: Who is Jimmy Ballgame. Edmonds? Yep 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites
colepenhagen 3,519 Posted March 25, 2020 Share Posted March 25, 2020 pujols griffey jr pedro (over kershaw because when he did it in the 90s) cal ripkin (under appreciated) Quote Link to post Share on other sites
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.