Add Shenault, Drop Mattison?

[laracco 159]

10 Team non PPR:

 

I have Dalvin Cook, so Mattison is just a little insurance right now. I have Chubb, J.Taylor, J.Kelley and McKinnon as my other RB's just looking to add a little more WR depth or a lottery ticket to my bench. Should I do this?

[rayruuu 170]

I like Shenault as much as the next guy, but I sleep a lot better at night cuffing the likes of Cook, Kamara, Zeke, etc - I know it feels like you're burning a bench spot, but the downside is ur out ur RB1. I always think of it this way: if someone said they could guarantee ur RB spot regardless of injury at the cost of 1 bench spot, would you do it? I always go yes - esp since Mattison has proved he can be the guy if needed

Help mine?

 

[laracco 159]

1 minute ago, rayruuu said:

I like Shenault as much as the next guy, but I sleep a lot better at night cuffing the likes of Cook, Kamara, Zeke, etc - I know it feels like you're burning a bench spot, but the downside is ur out ur RB1. I always think of it this way: if someone said they could guarantee ur RB spot regardless of injury at the cost of 1 bench spot, would you do it? I always go yes - esp since Mattison has proved he can be the guy if needed

Help mine?

 

Would you drop M.Pittman Jr for him instead? My other WR's are Golladay, Diontae Johnson, Lamb and Slayton? I fell like Pittman's role is going to increase now that Campbell is out and am scared to drop him.

[rayruuu 170]

would swap pittman for Shenault Jr, if not for the fact that you get Minshew at QB vs Rivers at QB, think they play from behind more and/or sling it more in JAX. THink Shenault is more talented imo too